Ask Mr. Science
page 15

 
arrow left arrow up arrow right
prev page
 
index
 
next page
 

 

swinging bridge
About building

There were a number of questions related to the subject of building
1) Do suspension bridges swing? Yes and no. See for example the Tacoma Narrows bridge collapse of 1940. This suspension bridge turned out to be sensitive to twisting caused by the wind. The swings got so bad that eventually the bridge was closed and it collapsed. After the disaster all new suspension bridges were designed to avoid this effect.

The Millennium Bridge in London (2000) was a pedestrian bridge, which swung so badly that people got seasick walking on it, and it was closed less than one day after opening for modifications. The reason for the swinging was that when people walk on a moving surface, they 'catch' themselves to regain their balance. Unfortunately this extra push made the swing of this bridge worse, especially when thousands of people on the bridge were all trying to stay on their feet at the same time. The problem was fixed eventually and the bridge was reopened.

Bridge designers try to limit the swings of suspension bridges to where they don't cause trouble, but sometimes unexpected things still happen.

2) How can concrete set up under water? For this, I made some concrete right there in the classroom. The recipe I used was 1 cup portland cement, 2 cups sand and 3 cups gravel. Mix in a big yoghurt container and pour into a 1-quart yoghurt container, right up to the top. Then I put plastic over the top, held in place with a rubber band, and put the whole thing into a bucket of water. How does the concrete get hard in a situation like that? The answer is that the mixture does not actually 'dry out' when it hardens. Rather, the water in the mixture undergoes a chemical reaction with the cement, which forms hard crystals which bind the sand and pebbles together - no water has to escape. In fact, if the mix dries out before it is cured, it turns back into the loose dry ingredients (sort of). That is why you have to cover up a freshly poured concrete sidewalk with plastic here in dry Santa Fe, to prevent the surface from drying out.

In the BBC science shack
at the University of Illinois 3) Why are arches so strong? free-standing arch If you want to span a large distance out of say granite, you can try to lay a granite beam between two columns. The weight of the beam will make it bow, and eventally it will snap in two. The reason is that stone materials (natural rock, brick, concrete) have great compressiona strength, but low tensional strength. That is, it is hard to crush a piece of blackboard chalk with your fingers, but you can easily break it in two by pulling on the ends. This is the opposite of string: great tensional strength, but no compressional strength at all.
OK, back to arches. So if you want to build something strong out of stone, make sure that all forces are compression forces. This is the beauty of arches: all vertical forces are transformed into compression forces along arch. One way to show this principle is with a free-standing arch made out of 2x4 blocks To determine the shape of such an arch, hang a string in a loose arch between two points, and trace its shape onto (double) corrugated cardboard. Turn it upside down and you have the shape of the arch. Divide it into sections (I cut it into 9 pieces), and lay out the shapes of the 2x4 blocks (more details here). To put up the arch, lay the blocks back on the cardboard, and tip the whole thing up till the arch is standing, then lay the cardboard back down. I left this in the classroom for the week, and apparently the kids had fun putting it up and knocking it down.

Artist Andy Goldsworthy makes free-standing arches in the field from found stone. Have a look here, or here.

4) How do they build underwater supports for bridges? As a Dutchman, I've seen this done numerous times: You build a caisson dam, or a coffer dam around the work site, and pump the water out. Then you're back to working on (soggy) land. If the site is very large, you can build yourself an entire temporary island to work on - build a ring-shaped dike in the water, and again pump the water out. Remove when done. This only works for sites that are not too deep.
(I'll look for some pictures here...)

How much does it cost to buy the materials to build a bridge? This was a follow-up question received the next week. Currently, the highway north of Santa Fe is under construction, and new overpasses will be built. On the project's website I found a pricetag of $45 million, which is the cost of a few miles of highway plus a viaduct. Put it in the ballpark. Likely most of this is for salaries, not for materials.

12 November 2002
 

glass with orange liquid
Evaporation


The actual question was: "If you have water with color in it, will it evaporate that color?"

3 December 2002





Suggestions, comments, greetings are greatly appreciated.
Just click here
and type away!

arrow left arrow up arrow right
prev page index next page
Back to my home page